Divine Simplicity and Modal Collapse: A Persistent Problem
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.24204/ejpr.2022.3414Keywords:
God, simplicity, freedom, modal collapseAbstract
In recent years the doctrine of divine simplicity has become a topic of interest in the philosophical theological community. In particular, the modal collapse argument against divine simplicity has garnered various responses from proponents of divine simplicity. Some even claiming that the modal collapse argument is invalid. It is our contention that these responses have either misunderstood or misstated the argument, and have thus missed the force of the objection. Our main aim is to clarify what the modal collapse argument in fact says, and explain why the recent responses do not succeed. In order to argue our case, we will proceed in several steps. First, we aim to systematically articulate the doctrine of divine simplicity. Second, articulate the Christian conviction that God is free to create any feasible world or no world at all. Third, argue that divine simplicity suffers a modal collapse and thus undermines God's freedom. Fourth, respond to potential objections to modal collapse. Fifth, we offer some concluding remarks.
References
Aquinas, Thomas. 1934. Summa Contra Gentiles. Translated by English Dominican Fathers. London: Burns, Oates, and Washbourne.
—. 1936. Summa Theologiae. Translated by English Dominican Fathers. London: Burns, Oates, and Washbourne.
Augustine, Saint. 1991. The Trinity. Translated by Edmund Hill. Hyde Park: New City Press.
Bergmann, Michael, and Jeffrey Brower. 2006. A Theistic Argument Against Platonism (and in Support of Truthmakers and Divine Simplicity). Vol. 2, in Oxford Studies in Metaphysics, edited by Dean W. Zimmerman. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Berkhof, Louis. 1984. Systematic Theology. Edinburgh: The Banner of Truth Trust.
Blowers, Paul M. 2012. Drama of the Divine Economy: Creator and Creation in Early Christian Theology and Piety. Oxford : Oxford University Press.
Bonaventure. 1963. The Works of Bonaventure: The Breviloquium II. Translated by Jose de Vinck. New York: St Anthony Guild Press.
Booth, Anthony Robert. 2017. Analytic Islamic Philosophy. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Burrell, David B. 2013. "Creatio Ex Nihilo Recovered." Modern Theology 29: 5-21.
Charnock, Stephen. 1864. The Complete Works of Stephen Charnock. Edited by James M'Cosh. Vol. 1. Edinburgh: James Nichol.
Church, Henry. 1638. Miscellanea Philo-Theologica. London: I.N. for John Rothwell.
Couenhoven, Jesse. 2018. Predestination: A Guide for the Perplexed. London: T&T Clarke.
Creel, Richard E. 1986. Divine Impassibility: An Essay in Philosophical Theology. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Crisp, Oliver D. 2019. Analyzing Doctrine: Toward a Systematic Theology. Waco: Baylor University Press.
—. 2014. Deviant Calvinism: Broadening Reformed Theology. Minneapolis: Fortress Press.
Dolezal, James E. 2017. All That Is In God: Evangelical Theology and the Challenge of Classical Christian Theism. Grand Rapids: Reformation Heritage Books.
—. 2011. God Without Parts: Divine Simplicity and the Metaphysics of God's Absoluteness. Eugene: Pickwick Publications.
Duby, Steven J. 2012. "Divine Simplicity, Divine Freedom, and the Contingency of Creation: Dogmatic Responses to Some Analytic Questions." Journal of Reformed Theology 6: 115-142.
—. 2016. Divine Simplicity: A Dogmatic Account. London: Bloomsbury.
Erickson, Millard J. 2004. Christian Theology. 2nd. Grand Rapids: Baker Books.
Feser, Edward. 2017. Five Proofs of the Existence of God. San Francisco: Ignatius Press.
Florio, Ciro De, and Aldo Frigerio. 2019. Divine Omniscience and Human Free Will: A Logical and Metaphysical Analysis. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.
Frost, Gloria. 2015. Aquinas and Scotus on the Source of Contingency. Vol. 2, in Oxford Studies in Medieval Philosophy, edited by Robert Pasnau. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Garcia, Laura L. 1992. "Divine Freedom and Creation." The Philosophical Quarterly 42: 191-213.
Grant, W. Matthews. 2019. Free Will and God's Universal Causality: The Dual Sources Account. London: Bloomsbury Academic.
Hasker, William. 2016. "Is Divine Simplicity a Mistake?" American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 90: 600-725.
Helm, Paul. 2010. Eternal God: A Study of God Without Time. Second. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Helm, Paul. 2015. "How Are We to Think of God's Freedom." European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 49-65.
Helm, Paul. 2001. "The Augustinian-Calvinist View." In Divine Foreknowledge: Four Views, edited by James K. Beilby and
Paul R. Eddy. Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press.
Highfield, Ron. 2015. The Faithful Creator: Affirming Creation and Providence in an Age of Anxiety. Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press.
Hughes, Christopher. 2018. "Aquinas on the Nature and Implications of Divine Simplicity." European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 10: 1-22.
Koons, Robert C. 2018. "Divine Persons as Relational Qua-Objects." Religious Studies 54: 337-357.
Kretzmann, Norman. 1991. "A General Problem of Creation: Why Would God Create Anything at All?" In Being and Goodness: The Concepts of the Good in Metaphysics and Philosophical Theology, edited by Scott MacDonald. London: Cornell University Press.
Leftow, Brian. 2016. "Two Pictures of Divine Choice." In Free Will and Classical Theism: The Significance of Freedom in Perfect Being Theology, edited by Hugh J. McCann. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Levering, Matthew. 2017. Engaging the Doctrine of Creation: Cosmos, Creatures, and the Wise and Good Creator. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic.
Lombard, Peter. 2007. The Sentences Book 1: The Mystery of the Trinity. Translated by Giulio Silano. Ontario: Pontifical Institute of Mediaeval Studies.
Lyons, Irenaeus of. 1885. "Irenaeus Against Heresies." In The Ante-Nicene Fathers Volume 1: The Apostolic Fathers with Justin Martyr and Irenaeus, edited by Alexander Roberts, James Donaldson and A. Cleveland Coxe. Buffalo: Christian Literature Company.
Mann, William E. 2015. God, Modality, and Morality. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Mawson, T.J. 2018. The Divine Attributes. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
McCann, Hugh J. 2012. Creation and the Sovereignty of God. Bloomington: Indiana University Press.
McCann, Hugh J. 2016. "Free Will and the Mythology of Causation." In Alternative Concepts of God: Essays on the Metaphysics of the Divine, edited by Andrei A. Buckareff and Yujin Nagasawa. New York: Oxford University Press.
McFarland, Ian A. 2014. From Nothing: A Theology of Creation. Louisville: Westminster John Knox Press.
Moreland, J.P., and William Lane Craig. 2017. Philosophical Foundations for a Christian Worldview. Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press.
Muller, Richard A. 2017. Divine Will and Human Choice: Freedom, Contingency, and Necessity in Early Modern Reformed Thought. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic.
Mullins, R.T. 2016. The End of the Timeless God. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Nemes, Steven. 2020. "Divine Simplicity Does Not Entail Modal Collapse." In Roses and Reasons: Philosophical Essays, edited by Carlos Frederico Calvet da Silveira and Alin Tat. Bucuresti: Eikon.
Pawl, Timothy. 2016. In Defense of Conciliar Christology: A Philosophical Essay. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Pink, Arthur W. 1975. The Attributes of God. Grand Rapids: Baker Books.
Poitiers, Hilary of. 1899. "On the Trinity." In A Select Library of the Nicene and Post-Nicene Fathers of the Christian Church Volume 9: St. Hilary of Poitiers, John of Damascus, edited by Philip Schaff and Henry Wace, translated by E.W. Watson. New York: Christian Literature Company.
Pruss, Alexander R. 2017. Divine Creative Freedom. Vol. 7, in Oxford Studies in Philosophy of Religion, edited by Jonathan L. Kvanvig. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Rea, Michael. 2014. Metaphysics: The Basics. New York: Routledge.
Rogers, Katherin A. Forthcoming. "Classical Theism and the Multiverse." International Journal for Philosophy of Religion.
Rogers, Katherin A. 2019. "Foreknowledge, Freedom, and Vicious Circles: Anselm vs Open Theism." In Philosophical Essays Against Open Theism, edited by Benjamin H. Arbour. London: Routledge.
—. 2000. Perfect Being Theology. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
—. 1997. The Anselmian Approach to God and Creation. Lewiston: The Edwin Mellen Press.
Rogers, Katherin A. 1996. "The Traditional Doctrine of Divine Simplicity." Religious Studies 32: 165-186.
Shedd, W.G.T. 1888. Dogmatic Theology. Vol. 1. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
Skrzypek, Jeremy W. 2017. "A Better Solution to the General Problem of Creation." European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 2017: 147-162.
Stump, Eleonore. 2016. The God of the Bible and the God of the Philosophers. Milwaukee: Marqueette University Press.
Tiessen, Terrance L. 2019. "A Calvinist Perspective in the Conversation About Middle Knowledge." In Calvinism and Middle Knowledge: A Conversation, edited by John D. Laing,
Kirk R. MacGregor and Greg Welty. Eugene: Pickwick Publications.
Tomaszewski, Christopher. 2019. "Collapsing the Modal Collapse Argument: On an Invalid Argument Against Divine Simplicity." Analysis 79: 275-284.
Vicens, Leigh, and Simon Kittle. 2019. God and Human Freedom. Cambridge : Cambridge University Press.
Waldrop, J.W. Forthcoming. "Modal Collapse and Modal Fallacies: No Easy Defense of Simplicity." American Philosophical Quarterly.
Ward, Keith. 2015. Christ and the Cosmos: A Reformulation of Trinitarian Doctrine. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Webster, John. 2013. ""Love is Also a Lover": Creatio Ex Nihilo and Creaturely Goodness." Modern Theology 29: 156-171.
Webster, John. 2010. "Trinity and Creation." International Journal of Systematic Theology 12: 4-19.
Wolterstorff, Nicholas. 2010. Inquiring About God. Edited by Terence Cuneo. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
